How to Evaluate an RFP for a Travel Management Company (+Free Scorecard)
.avif)
Snapshot
- Score every RFP response against the same weighted criteria, agreed before responses arrive rather than after.
- The scorecard below weights pricing transparency and policy control at 20% each. Copy it and change the weights to match your priorities.
- Rate each vendor out of 5, multiply by weight, total the column. The arithmetic narrows the field; it does not pick the winner.
- Six red flags predict post-signature problems, and boilerplate that restates your own questions is the most common.
- Demo two or three vendors, not five, and include frequent travelers rather than only the buying panel.
- Still drafting the RFP itself? That is a separate job, covered in the companion guide.
The business travel industry has seen dramatic changes in recent years, from cutting-edge technology to evolving travel trends. This has placed a heavy responsibility on travel managers, who are now tasked with overseeing every aspect of a business trip, from when it's announced until the traveler returns home.
To manage this increased responsibility, travel managers must partner with a tech-savvy Travel Management Company (TMC) that offers advanced software solutions. These tools help control costs, elevate the travel experience, and prioritize traveler safety.
But how do you know which TMC is the right fit for your company? The answer lies in the RFP – Request for Proposal. Using an RFP evaluation process, you can compare and assess travel management solutions based on key criteria.
In this blog, we’ll break down what an RFP is, how to evaluate one, and how to choose the best TMC based on RFP responses to ensure a seamless, efficient, and cost-effective travel management experience.
What is an RFP?
An RFP, or Request for Proposal, is a formal document that organizations use to solicit proposals from potential vendors or service providers. It’s a common practice in industries like business travel management, where companies need to evaluate multiple solutions to find the best fit for their needs. Essentially, an RFP outlines the company’s requirements and invites vendors to submit detailed proposals that explain how they can meet those needs.
In the context of travel management, an RFP helps businesses assess various Travel Management Companies (TMCs) based on specific criteria like cost, technology, services offered, and the ability to ensure traveler safety. It typically includes a description of the company’s travel policies, goals, and any challenges the company is facing, allowing vendors to tailor their responses accordingly.
By using an RFP, companies ensure they are selecting a travel management solution that aligns with their goals, budget, and priorities, leading to better travel experiences and improved cost management. It’s a critical step in making strategic, data-driven decisions when choosing a TMC or any service provider. To learn more about how much you can save by choosing the right TMC through business travel RFPs, check out the free calculator tools.
Free RFP evaluation scorecard for travel management services
Copy this scorecard into a spreadsheet and score each vendor out of 5 against every criterion. Multiply by the weight, total the column, and the ranking falls out of the arithmetic rather than out of whoever demoed last.
The weights below are a starting point for a mid-market program. Change them to match your own priorities, but agree to them before responses arrive rather than after.
The scoring worksheet
Lay the vendors out side by side. Weighted score is the raw score multiplied by the weight, and the totals are what you take to the decision meeting.
Red flags in an RFP response
Six patterns that predict problems after signature. None is automatically disqualifying, but each one is worth a follow-up question before scoring.
Scoring only works if the RFP asked the right questions in the first place. If you are still drafting, the RFP for travel management services template and question bank covers the issuing side.
How to Evaluate RFP Responses from TMCs: Key Factors
Before evaluating the RFPs for travel management services, it's essential to have a list of factors that align with your company's needs. This will help you critically analyze each element during selection and speed up the evaluation process.
Some essential factors to look out for are:
1. Expertise
While evaluating the travel management company, you should look into the company's expertise over RFPs. Look for the experience and knowledge base of the vendor.
Here are a few questions you must ask:
- A brief company background
- How long have they been in the industry?
- Who are their major clients and what is the average account size of each client?
With the responses to these questions, you will get an idea of the expertise they have in your industry or as a travel management company in general. Moreover, you need to check whether the travel management company has successfully delivered for clients.
Make sure you check references and case studies of different clients that include everything about how the travel solution provider helped the client solve a particular problem.
2. The TMC Pricing Structure
The pricing framework of the TMC holds considerable importance in assessing the responses to your RFP for travel management services. It's imperative to guarantee that the pricing model remains transparent, devoid of concealed fees such as customization charges or service costs.
Per-trip pricing is the structure that makes this easiest to verify. A single amount covering booking, cancellation, support and miscellaneous charges, quoted before the trip, is a number you can compare across vendors. ITILITE prices this way, and so do several others on most shortlists, so ask every respondent to state which structure they are quoting.
Your travel bill at the end of the month won't be inflated with various secret charges. This clean pricing will help you keep track of T&E spending and reduce overall costs.
3. Round-the-Clock Travel Support
The safety of your employees should be your priority. And especially after the COVID-19 pandemic, travelers are becoming more conscious about their safety. Not just that, other safety challenges such as political unrest, cybercrime, natural calamities, etc can also affect travelers’ safety.
When business travelers are abroad, it is vital to give them 24/7 support to help them navigate everything easily in a new and foreign place.
4. Business Travel Inventory
The travel management company should offer your employees access to global travel inventory including transportation such as airplanes, trains, rental cars, etc., and accommodation such as hotels, studio apartments, etc.
The employees should be able to check the availability of hotel rooms, flights, to make and confirm reservations in real-time. Apart from this, they should also give offers on group travel bookings, leisure travel, and more. This will also help you in cost savings for your company.
5. State-of-the-art Technology
Even before you start the RFP process, a go-live time is set in your mind. Make sure the travel management company you choose has integration capabilities and can meet your timelines.
Furthermore, consider how easily changes can be made in their T&E platform to adapt to your company’s unique requirements. Does it have an inbuilt travel policy feature? Is there flexibility for customizing categories and travel policy features? Does it provide real-time data visibility?
Apart from this, the TMC’s travel management platform must have a mobile app as well as browser-based access. This factor is important as the number of employees filing expenses through the convenience of their mobile phones has increased over the years.
This convenience is what will help you get your employees to adopt the T&E solution you choose for your company.
How to select the right TMC from RFP responses
Total the weighted scores first, then do three things before deciding, because the arithmetic narrows the field rather than picking the winner.
Run the top two through a demo with real travelers. Score the platform with people who will use it daily, not only with the panel. A tool that scores well on paper and badly with a frequent traveler will not get adopted, and low adoption undoes every saving in the business case.
Call references yourself. Ask what the implementation actually took versus what was quoted, what the first invoice looked like against the proposal, and what they would negotiate differently. Vendors supply references who will speak well of them, so the useful questions are about surprises rather than satisfaction.
Check the gap between the two top scores. If it is inside a few points, the decision is not really about capability. It is about fit, account team and contract terms, and it is worth saying so openly rather than manufacturing a tiebreak from a feature nobody will use.
ITILITE responds to RFPs scored this way regularly, and the criteria that most often separate responses are pricing transparency and whether policy is enforced at booking rather than at review. Those are the two rows worth weighting heaviest whoever you are comparing. If you want the shortlist itself, the top 10 corporate travel management companies and corporate travel management tools and software breakdowns are a reasonable starting point.
FAQ
How do you evaluate an RFP for a travel management company?
Score every response against the same weighted criteria, agreed before responses arrive. Rate each vendor out of 5 on pricing transparency, technology and policy control, support, inventory, implementation, reporting, financial standing and references, multiply by the weights, and total. The arithmetic narrows the field; demos and reference calls decide it.
What weighting should you use in a TMC scorecard?
For a mid-market program, 20% each to pricing transparency and technology, 15% each to support and inventory, 10% each to implementation and reporting, and 5% each to financial standing and references. Adjust to your own priorities, but set the weights before you read a single response.
What are the red flags in a TMC RFP response?
Boilerplate that restates your questions, pricing supplied in a format you did not request, policy control described as "visibility" rather than enforcement, support hours quoted with no response targets, integrations listed without naming your systems, and a reference list containing only recent wins.
How many vendors should reach the demo stage?
Two or three. Demoing five is how evaluation panels lose weeks and interest. Use the scorecard to cut the field, then spend real time with the shortlist, including at least one session with frequent travelers rather than only the buying panel.
Should the cheapest RFP response win?
Not usually. Price belongs in the scorecard at a defined weight rather than as a tiebreak, because the cheapest quote often excludes support, custom reporting or rate loading that then appears as a line item later. Compare all-in cost for your actual volume, not headline fees.
What happens after you select a TMC from the RFP?
Contracting and implementation, which is where timelines slip. Agree the implementation plan, data migration approach and go-live date in the contract rather than afterwards, and confirm what happens to bookings already in the incumbent's system on the day you switch.
I’ll be honest: I haven’t spent my life living out of a suitcase for business, but I’ve spent it obsessing over the systems of those who do. At ITILITE, I bridge that gap through relentless, intentional research. I dig deep into the data so the insights reaching you aren’t just SaaS noise. If you want to share your travel experiences or talk shop about expenses, find me on LinkedIn.
Score your travel management RFP responses
A fully integrated corporate travel management software that dramatically reduces spends while improving user experience
